A distinguished group of academics, researchers, and public figures—including prominent voices from Harvard University and University College London—has joined an alternative independent review examining the University of Cambridge’s controversial appointment of the late sociologist Jason Arday.
The Committee for Academic Freedom (CAF) has officially named its high-profile review panel, which features Stephen Pinker, a renowned psychologist and co-president of the council on academic freedom at Harvard University; Robert Tombs, a respected professor of French history at the University of Cambridge; and Alice Sullivan, a sociologist at University College London (UCL). Sullivan previously led the U.K. government-commissioned independent review of data, statistics, and research concerning sex and gender.
They are joined on the independent panel by political theorist and Labour life peer Maurice Glasman, who formerly served as a professor at St. Mary’s University in Twickenham.
The alternative inquiry has been commissioned separately by the CAF to thoroughly explore “the circumstances surrounding” Dr. Arday’s appointment to a professorship within Cambridge’s Faculty of Education back in 2023.
The appointment and its aftermath drew intense public scrutiny following allegations of plagiarism. Amid the heavy pressure and public spotlight, Dr. Arday resigned from his position. Tragically, he was later found dead in his home on August 14.
In the wake of these events, the University of Cambridge launched its own internal investigation into what transpired. Vice-Chancellor Deborah Prentice has publicly promised that the university’s probe will be both independent and rigorous. However, skepticism remains widespread across the higher education sector regarding the potential efficacy and scope of an internal institutional review.
According to the CAF, the organization is funding and launching its own separate probe to address mounting disquiet surrounding what it describes as a “material change in the language and emphasis of Cambridge’s own review following Arday’s death.” The CAF argues that this shift risks prejudging the legitimacy of the fierce scrutiny Dr. Arday faced during his lifetime and threatens to displace the foundational questions that Cambridge itself had initially identified for formal investigation.
Specifically, the CAF has expressed deep concern that the Cambridge-led review—the first part of which is scheduled to be led by former chief Crown prosecutor Nazir Afzal—will focus disproportionately on what Vice-Chancellor Prentice has termed the “appalling period of external criticism and focus” that Dr. Arday endured. The CAF contends that phrasing of this nature “risks prejudging” vital aspects of the inquiry by framing the external scrutiny itself as the primary wrong, rather than looking objectively at the appointment processes and institutional standards involved.
The University of Cambridge has been approached for formal comment regarding these accusations and the establishment of the parallel academic inquiry.

The CAF-commissioned probe will be chaired by Swaran Singh, a professor of social and community psychiatry at the University of Warwick and a Conservative life peer. Professor Singh brings prior high-level investigative experience to the role, having previously chaired the independent investigation into accusations of discrimination and Islamophobia within the Conservative Party.
The independent review is expected to report its findings within four to six months. Because the probe is non-statutory, it does not possess formal legal powers to compel witnesses or individuals to provide evidence. Nevertheless, its investigative work will be led by veteran journalist Nick Wallis—widely recognized for his exhaustive investigative work on the U.K.’s Post Office Horizon scandal—alongside a dedicated research team.
Edward Skidelsky, a philosopher at the University of Exeter and director of the CAF, emphasized that the review has commenced with “no predetermined conclusion.”
“The questions raised by this tragic case go to the heart of several concerns that recur in CAF’s casework involving academics across the U.K.: how far nonstatutory concepts and institutional orthodoxies can influence recruitment, promotion and judgments of academic merit, and whether university systems are capable of correcting course when those considerations come into tension with academic standards,” Mr. Skidelsky stated.
Freddie Attenborough, the research and communications manager at the CAF, stressed that while his organization has commissioned the review, the panel has been directed to produce its findings completely independently of the committee itself.
However, Mr. Attenborough noted that the organization firmly believes the Arday case brings into sharp relief wider concerns frequently raised by its academic members. Speaking to Times Higher Education, he explained that the organization routinely hears from academics across Cambridge and other institutions who voice deep reservations about equality, diversity, and inclusion (EDI) policies as they apply to recruitment, appointments, and candidate selection.
“People come to us and say, ‘We think some of these policies go beyond what equality law permits, or misstate the law on positive action.’ So we think there are wider issues around that,” Mr. Attenborough said.
He added that while there is an undeniable personal tragedy at the center of the case—and genuine institutional questions for Cambridge to explore regarding staff welfare—the situation has simultaneously illuminated broader structural questions surrounding academic standards, merit, and institutional decision-making.
“Our academic supporters want clarity about what happened in Dr. Arday’s case and the processes that were followed,” Mr. Attenborough concluded.