SPOILER ALERT: This article contains major spoilers for “Clayface,” now playing in theaters.

For fans of the Caped Crusader, the wait for the next chapter in Matt Reeves and Robert Pattinson’s standalone saga remains ongoing. However, audiences seeking an immediate, visceral entry point into the rebooted DC Universe (DCU) need look no further than the gritty, R-rated transformation of one of Gotham City’s most tragic figures. “Clayface,” the latest project to emerge from the DC stable, pivots away from the traditional superhero spectacle, opting instead for a disturbing, character-driven descent into body horror that serves as an unexpected foundation for the studio’s new shared cinematic world.

Directed by James Watkins with a screenplay based on a story by horror maestro Mike Flanagan, the film is a departure from the high-flying heroics usually associated with DC. The narrative centers on Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries), an A-list actor whose life is irrevocably shattered after a brutal encounter with a ruthless mobster leaves him horribly disfigured. Stripped of his identity, his livelihood, and his physical agency, Hagen turns to an experimental medical procedure pioneered by Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie). While the procedure ostensibly repairs the damage, it triggers a catastrophic side effect: Hagen begins to transform into a shifting, mud-like entity.

As the condition progresses, Hagen’s cellular structure gains the terrifying ability to reshape his body into the likeness of others—including his own tormentors, his peers, or even his estranged father, played in a fleeting, haunting cameo by Aaron Paul. As the lines between man and monster blur, so too do the boundaries of his sanity. Driven by a vengeful thirst for retribution, Hagen uses his horrific new abilities to systematically dismantle the criminal underworld that destroyed him. The film reaches its bleak, inevitable conclusion with Hagen having purged his enemies—and an unfortunate number of innocents—only to resign himself to a solitary, subterranean existence as a reclusive mud monster lurking in the sewers of Gotham.

The Evolution of a Classic Villain

Clayface has long been a fixture in the Batman mythos, appearing across decades of comics, animated series, and video games. While characters like Basil Karlo are often the primary touchstone for the name, this film deliberately opts for the Matt Hagen iteration. According to Watkins, this choice was pivotal to grounding the horror in a contemporary, relatable framework.

“It was really landed by Mike Flanagan and the script,” Watkins explains. “I read all of them, Basil Karlo and all, afterward because there are bits and bobs that are kind of cherry-picked from all over the place. But the key journey, and that’s what Mike had chosen, was the Matt Hagen version. If you’d have gone with Basil Karlo, it’s a little bit too gothic or too hard to do in such a modern idiom. The Matt Hagen is a more relatable version. Whether it’s Basil Karlo and Boris Karloff, there are all those characters that it’s referring back to in the Golden Age of Hollywood, that sort of thing. This is something that can sit in our contemporary time.”

Constructing a New Gotham

Beyond the character study, “Clayface” provides the first substantial live-action glimpse of Gotham City within James Gunn’s rebooted DC Universe. While the universe was inaugurated with the bright, optimistic tones of Metropolis in last year’s “Superman,” “Clayface” offers a starkly different aesthetic for DC’s most famous urban sprawl. Watkins notes that the production design team, led by James Price, worked to ensure the city functioned as a living, breathing character rather than just a backdrop.

“We deliberately wanted it to be a bit muddy,” Watkins says. “We wanted this oppressive world where the buildings really dominate. We looked at a lot of 1930s German expressionist cinema with huge dominant buildings and the odd angles and the noir-ish shadows. We also looked at street photography from New York from the ’70s, the ’80s and the ’90s. It was all before New York had been cleaned up. The lighting is different. It’s a lot of neon. There’s a lot of practical lighting. There’s a lot of dirt and eccentricity on the street.”

‘Clayface’ Director James Watkins Explains That [SPOILER] Cameo, Introducing Gotham City to the DC Universe and All the Shape-Shifting Kills

This visual language was designed to create a deliberate friction between Gotham and other locales in the DCU. “We wanted to definitely frame Gotham as a contrast to Coast City, with the colors, the bright sunshine, the sky, the sea,” Watkins adds. “You see verdant greens and textures and stuff like that, which you don’t really see in Gotham. You barely see the sky, and it’s a very heavy atmosphere.”

The Craft of Practical Terror

A defining feature of “Clayface” is its reliance on practical effects to render its disturbing visuals. Watkins, a veteran of the horror genre, expressed a clear preference for physical reality over digital augmentation whenever possible. This was particularly evident during the nightclub sequence, where Hagen uses his shapeshifting powers to execute a lethal revenge plot. The production utilized “in-camera wipes,” repeating setups with different actors emerging from behind pillars to simulate the instant morphing effect.

“My guiding thing is if I can do it practically, I will try and do it practically,” Watkins explains. This extended to the more gruesome moments, such as the suffocation of the character Corey. “The actual pulling into the body is practical with augmentation, but he is wearing a rig on his body with a big cavity in it so he could pull Josh [James], who plays Corey, into his chest. That is prosthetic makeup, not VFX. There’s a tactile quality that just reads when it’s on camera, that I think is very hard to replicate.”

The team even went as far as creating a specialized rig for the scene where Hagen must manually cut strips of clay from his eyes. Using contact lenses, prosthetic layers, and a moving gimbal to simulate the jolts of the bathroom environment, the team ensured the scene felt grounded and perilous. To capture the specific, unquantifiable look of the monster, the crew produced roughly 19 different iterations of the creature and upwards of 65 stages of prosthetic makeup for Harries to endure throughout the production.

A Standalone Vision

The cameo appearance of Aaron Paul as Hagen’s father serves as one of the film’s few nods to the broader acting landscape, but Watkins is quick to point out that the film avoids the trend of over-stuffing the narrative with Easter eggs or teases for future installments.

“I actually think there are lots of Easter eggs that I probably don’t even know about because the graphics department was always throwing in posters and stuff,” Watkins says. “What I really responded to was the fact that it was a standalone story, and so for me to read that and then to try and get too cute or crowbar something in that wasn’t merited to the narrative felt gimmicky, I suppose. There was zero pressure to do it. I signed up to a certain story, which I believed in, and I just tried to tell that to the best of my abilities.”

As for where the mud-covered monster might appear next—or whether he is destined to cross paths with a future iteration of the Dark Knight—Watkins remains focused on the film as a self-contained experience. “That’s a question for James Gunn,” he notes. “I liked the standalone nature of it. I liked how it felt like it introduced a character. But I wasn’t trying to introduce the character to go, ‘OK, what next?’ I was trying to introduce the character as a full meal in itself.”