By Paul Brody
Do you remember Pets.com? It raised $110 million from venture capital firms, including Amazon, to build an online retail business where people could order pet toys and dog food to be delivered directly to their doorsteps.
The company ultimately crashed and burned, leaving a cautionary tale in its wake that taught the early e-commerce industry an important lesson: you cannot profitably ship a heavy, 50-pound bag of dog food to a retail customer’s doorstep under the cost structures of the time.
As online retail entrepreneur Ed Baum famously asked in a 2001 postmortem analysis: “Did Pets.com’s business plan assume the invention of transporters to magically move bags of pet food without shipping costs?”
Please, whatever you do, don’t share this sentiment with the executives at Chewy; they might not realize their modern business model allegedly doesn’t work. Chewy reported a staggering $12.6 billion in sales and $223 million in net income in its latest fiscal year.
The real lesson of Pets.com wasn’t that shipping heavy pet supplies was fundamentally a bad idea. Instead, the true takeaway was that the idea arrived well before the logistics infrastructure, consumer habits, and unit economics required to make it economically viable were fully developed.
As it was with chew toys and dog food decades ago, so it may soon be with enterprise blockchains.
Collectively, the cryptocurrency and enterprise technology industry probably incinerated just as much capital trying to pioneer enterprise blockchain solutions between 2017 and 2023 as Pets.com did, perhaps even more. Yet, the dozens of corporate entities and startups that aggressively pursued enterprise blockchain applications were not entirely delusional; they were simply operating too early in the technological lifecycle.
Why Businesses Need Enterprise Blockchains
It is not difficult to understand the fundamental appeal of enterprise blockchain solutions, at least on a superficial level. Nearly all enterprise systems in use today tend to fail right at the operational boundaries between separate corporate entities. Broadly speaking, these failures manifest in two distinct modes.
The first is the original, legacy failure mode, where inter-company collaboration data is constantly out of sync. In this fragmented world, enterprise IT systems operate like isolated islands, communicating asynchronously with each other through informal digital text messages and emailed spreadsheets. This approach is undeniably cheap and easy to set up initially, provided an organization does not mind constantly operating with slightly inaccurate, delayed, or conflicting information.
The second failure mode is the costly, real-time proprietary integration. In this scenario, powerful industry leaders politely request their key suppliers and strategic partners to join their closed, proprietary, but always-on digital networks.
These integrated systems are extraordinarily costly to build and maintain, but they generally work quite well once established. Ultimately, they leave participants with a business version of Stockholm syndrome, where companies gradually come to appreciate the thoroughness and efficiency of the digital choke-hold they find themselves trapped in.
Decentralized blockchains offered a significantly better path forward by introducing shared information and business logic across an open, neutral ecosystem. They promised all the operational benefits of a proprietary network in terms of real-time visibility and workflow efficiency, but without the stifling vendor lock-in.

Sometime around 2017, this proposition started to look like an obvious, undeniable good idea to corporate boardrooms. Venture capital and corporate investment poured in rapidly, high-profile industry consortia were launched, carefully drafted press releases were distributed globally, and then nearly the entire sector crashed and burned.
Initiatives like TradeLens, We.Trade, Contour, B3i, ASX Chess, and Everledger all arrived with immense fanfare and subsequently vanished within just a few short years.
Although there is a vast amount of nuance hidden within the specific details of each individual corporate failure, they all largely shared one fundamental flaw: they had to resort to unnatural architectural workarounds to make up for the absolute lack of native privacy available on public blockchains.
Companies Need Privacy, Not Transparency
No commercial enterprise wants its direct competitors to see its sensitive operational data, pricing strategies, or supply chain movements in exhaustive detail. In the early days of enterprise blockchain, this corporate reality meant that builders had to construct private, permissioned networks and then layer on countless non-blockchain-like mechanisms to try and keep business information secure from prying eyes.
The resulting systems were uniformly slow, excessively expensive, and ultimately failed to gain meaningful, long-term commercial traction across global industries.
It is difficult to understate the sheer magnitude of the corporate bloodbath among startups and established tech firms that tried and failed to make enterprise blockchain viable during that era. A quick search through recent technology history reveals at least 18 different enterprise blockchain ventures that collapsed, several of which were heavily backed by household-name institutions.
Many of these failed projects boasted backing from major global financial institutions like Deutsche Bank and HSBC, alongside legacy technology giants like IBM. However, having pedigreed corporate parents and massive brand recognition made no practical difference; the lack of native privacy crippled the technology, and the financial results were dismal.
The few survivors of that era have largely “de-chained” themselves, quietly abandoning their blockchain theater and reverting to a classic software-as-a-service or cloud-based enterprise model. Furthermore, many enterprise companies that tested these early permissioned systems as end users walked away from the experience with a definitive, lasting conclusion: they tried blockchain, and it simply did not work for their business operations.
That prevailing industry attitude is deeply unfortunate, because the technological landscape has fundamentally changed.
Blockchains Today Have Scalability, Privacy and Liquidity
Modern blockchain infrastructure has finally achieved true enterprise-grade scalability. Back in 2020, the Ethereum network handled roughly 1 million transactions per day, and gas fees for individual transactions periodically spiked to $30 or $50 when network demand surged.
Today, the vast majority of transactions are executed for fractions of a penny, and network capacity is scaling rapidly toward billions of transactions daily. Industry insiders rarely talk about the famous blockchain "trilemma" anymore because the engineering hurdles have been largely overcome; Ethereum is simultaneously decentralized and massively scaled.
The privacy landscape has undergone an equally dramatic transformation. While raw transparency remains the default setting for public ledgers, a vast array of sophisticated privacy tools and cryptographic systems are now commercially available, ranging from specialized privacy pools to zero-knowledge rollups and dedicated privacy-focused networks.
On top of these developments, major ecosystems like Ethereum are actively building modular tools that will integrate foundational elements of privacy directly at multiple layers of the network architecture. Consequently, it is now entirely feasible to run complex business operations at massive scale while maintaining a remarkably high degree of data privacy.

Finally, there is the matter of institutional liquidity and monetary rails. Financial value is rapidly moving onchain. Regulatory bodies around the world have increasingly established clear frameworks for stablecoins, triggering a massive surge of institutional liquidity, with global transaction volumes reaching nearly $1.8 trillion in June alone.
When organizations combine the operational efficiencies of modern blockchains with these powerful financial rails, they unlock something that enterprise leaders have never truly possessed before: a unified, global ecosystem where a company can buy, sell, and move physical assets, and instantly get paid for them within the exact same transactional environment.
The potential return on investment from every single component of this modern technical equation is massive. When combined, they can yield colossal strategic advantages for participating enterprises.
Partners at management consulting firm McKinsey previously found that advanced digital supply chain tools could make inventory reductions of 35% to 75% possible through enhanced predictive planning and visibility.
Even from a more conservative perspective rooted in real-world industry experience, simply eliminating the endless cascades of traditional spreadsheets and electronic data interchange messages allows firms to run most complex supply chains with about 20% less inventory while maintaining the exact same customer service levels. In most major industrial sectors, that operational shift is worth billions of dollars in liberated working capital.
The benefits extend far beyond inventory management. Smart contracts drastically reduce the time required to handle complicated business contract rules and terms from days down to mere minutes, while cutting administrative overhead costs in half.
As a prominent example, Microsoft began migrating its expansive Xbox video game network onto smart contracts to handle developer royalties, successfully reducing the time required to access monthly royalty statements from 45 days down to just four minutes. All of this was accomplished while effortlessly processing more than 2 million transactions a day.
Once a company’s physical inventories, commercial contracts, purchase orders, and invoices are all maintained transparently onchain, it becomes significantly easier to optimize working capital directly.
When a business can cryptographically prove that its purchase order originates from a premier, top-tier corporate buyer, it can access vital commercial credit at lower interest rates. Similarly, when an organization maintains complete, tamper-proof visibility into inventory locations and delivery status, it can factor receivables immediately and efficiently.
The commercial possibilities and the financial returns are simply too large to ignore, and the operational use cases are obvious. It is finally time for enterprises to try again.
Paul Brody is the Founder and CEO of Nightfall Networks, a blockchain technology company focused on building robust privacy systems for enterprise users. He is the former Global Blockchain Leader at EY and the former Chairman of the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance.