EAST LANSING, Mich. — A second Michigan State University Board of Trustees member has filed a federal lawsuit against top university board leaders, challenging strict rules that prohibit trustees from publicly disagreeing with the board majority and university administrators.
The lawsuit, filed Wednesday in the U.S. District Court for Michigan’s Western District, marks a significant escalation in ongoing internal governance battles at the prominent public institution. Trustee Michael Balow is suing Board Chair Brianna Scott and Board Secretary and Chief of Staff Stefan Fletcher, alleging that the university’s recently revised Code of Ethics and Conduct violates the First and 14th Amendments of the U.S. Constitution by imposing unconstitutional restrictions on elected officials’ right to free expression.
Balow’s legal challenge follows a similar lawsuit filed just last week by fellow MSU Trustee Rema Vassar, who also took legal action against board members and university officials over the restrictive code and other operational disputes. The mounting litigation highlights deep ideological and structural divisions within the governing body of one of the nation’s largest public universities, raising critical questions about the balance between institutional unity and the constitutionally protected speech of democratically elected public servants.
According to Balow’s lawsuit, the current enforcement mechanisms and guidelines governing the MSU board create an environment of overt viewpoint discrimination. The filing points out a stark double standard regarding how speech is monitored and sanctioned within the leadership ranks of the university.
"Trustees may praise MSU’s leadership all they want, but they face sanctions if they publicly criticize it," Balow’s lawsuit states, characterizing the disciplinary framework as "blatant viewpoint discrimination, repugnant to our Constitution and political tradition."
The legal challenge places particular emphasis on the severe penalties attached to potential violations of the code. Because MSU trustees are elected directly by the voters of Michigan to serve as independent stewards of the public university, Balow’s suit stresses that the threat of sanctions—which explicitly includes "potential removal from office"—amounts to an unlawful infringement on the electorate’s right to representation and the trustee’s freedom of speech.
The controversy centers on specific language within the updated Ethics Code that dictates how board members must conduct themselves publicly and internally. The lawsuit details several provisions of the revised code that Balow and his legal team argue are overly broad, vague, and designed to silence dissenting voices on the panel.

Specifically, the revised Ethics Code requires Balow and his fellow trustees to "uphold the university’s reputation," explicitly prohibits the sharing of "inaccurate, misleading, or false information concerning the university," and directs members to "support" rather than "undermine" majority board decisions. Furthermore, the code mandates a policy of "loyal opposition," which stipulates that any dissenting views or criticisms must be raised exclusively behind closed doors in designated "appropriate settings" rather than communicated to the public or the university community at large.
In his complaint, Balow asserts that these rules are not merely abstract guidelines but are actively being used to marginalize him and suppress his political and institutional oversight. He notes that Board Chair Scott and Chief of Staff Fletcher have already subjected him to retaliatory measures for speaking out. According to the court filing, these actions have included excluding him from official university events and denying the reimbursement of standard travel and conference expenses incurred in the line of his elected duties.
The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), a prominent national civil liberties organization specializing in campus free speech and constitutional rights, is representing Balow in the federal lawsuit alongside local counsel. Greg Greubel, a senior attorney at FIRE, offered a sharp critique of the board’s leadership and their approach to governance in a press statement accompanying the legal filing.
"The people of Michigan elected Michael to be a watchdog, not a lapdog," Greubel said, summarizing the core argument that elected trustees have a fiduciary and democratic duty to question administrative policies and voice independent opinions without fear of institutional retaliation.
In response to the growing legal pressure and the specific allegations raised in Balow’s complaint, Board Chair Brianna Scott defended the necessity and integrity of the board’s conduct guidelines. In an emailed statement regarding the lawsuit, Scott drew a parallel between the university’s internal governance rules and the institutional standards upheld by elected legislative bodies.
Scott likened the code to the rules and regulations that state legislatures routinely enact to govern the professional conduct and ethical obligations of their own members. She maintained that the primary purpose of the MSU Code of Ethics and Conduct is institutional stability and effective stewardship, stating that the code "is to help ensure the Board can effectively govern in service to students, faculty, staff, parents, research partners, taxpayers and the broader public."
The legal battles initiated by Balow and Vassar underscore a turbulent period for Michigan State University’s leadership, as questions regarding transparency, accountability, and the boundaries of executive authority continue to play out in both public forums and federal court. With two sitting trustees now seeking judicial intervention to overturn parts of the board’s ethical framework, the outcome of these lawsuits could establish significant legal precedents regarding the First Amendment rights of elected officials serving on public university governing boards across the country.