There is an urgent crisis quietly unfolding within the architecture of modern education, and it demands our most candid and uncompromising attention. When we strip away the relentless corporate and administrative rhetoric surrounding artificial intelligence—the glossy claims of inevitability, boundless innovation, and systemic progress that are rarely subjected to rigorous scrutiny—we are left to confront the profound dangers that AI introduces not only to individual students, but to the health of society at large. Left unchecked, the widespread integration of automated technologies into schools and colleges risks undermining the very foundations of democracy. This subversion does not happen in spite of AI’s growing prevalence in classrooms across the country, but precisely because of it. To fully grasp the gravity of this trajectory, we must look backward to the insights of one of the twentieth century’s most influential educational theorists, Paulo Freire.
Writing in his seminal 1968 manifesto, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, Freire detailed the mechanisms by which authoritarian governments weaponize their educational systems. The primary goal of such regimes is to maintain a submissive populace incapable of questioning existing power structures. Because critical reasoning naturally breeds unrest, dissent, and revolutionary potential, authoritarian states exert strict control over both the formal curriculum and the pedagogical strategies deployed within classrooms. By mandating rote obedience and systematically eliminating any practice that cultivates higher-order cognitive skills, these systems ensure compliance.
Freire termed this oppressive methodology the "banking concept" of education. Under this model, the educational process is transformed into an act of depositing, where students function merely as depositories and the teacher acts as the sole depositor. Rather than engaging in genuine communication, the instructor issues communiqués and makes intellectual deposits that students are expected to patiently receive, memorize, and mechanically repeat. Freire identified the primary hallmarks of this approach as rigid hierarchies, uninterrupted lecturing, and a total absence of genuine student agency. Crucially, he warned that even well-meaning educators frequently stumble into the banking trap simply because they lack the ability—or the institutional willingness—to scrutinize the external expectations imposed upon them.
The consequences of this instructional model are deeply dehumanizing. Students are conditioned to view themselves as passive objects upon whom things are acted, rather than as active transformers of their own world. Even on its own, this outcome represents the antithesis of a meaningful education. When pushed to its logical conclusion, however, the deliberate stifling of creativity and cognitive ingenuity cultivates the exact brand of apathy and submission that serves the interests of those seeking absolute control.
Yet the banking concept is merely one historical archetype of a pedagogical tool utilized for subjugation. We can observe the exact same mechanical levers of oppression at work in any educational initiative heavily promoted by political leaders that simultaneously functions to anesthetize critical thinking.
Viewed through this analytical lens, the rapid, uncritical integration of artificial intelligence into contemporary classrooms emerges as a modernized pedagogy of the oppressed. AI is currently being promoted with immense political backing by government entities, including the federal administration in the United States, alongside school boards and university administrators nationwide. Concurrently, a growing body of empirical research demonstrates that students who rely on artificial intelligence to execute challenging cognitive tasks—such as synthesizing complex texts, brainstorming ideas, constructing arguments, and analyzing information—exhibit less deep learning over time.
More alarmingly, by outsourcing the difficult, often uncomfortable labor of independent thinking to algorithms, students risk failing to develop these vital cognitive faculties in the first place. This vulnerability is not restricted to younger learners; college and university students are proving just as susceptible to the detrimental effects of cognitive offloading.
For educators and public intellectuals alike, this trend serves as a recipe for institutional and societal disaster. Much like the banking model that Freire abhorred, AI threatens to make students the authors of their own intellectual diminishment by eroding their capacity for independent thought and thoroughly dehumanizing the educational endeavor. Furthermore, these technologies risk exacerbating existing systemic inequities along socioeconomic lines, further penalizing vulnerable populations and contributing to the ongoing debasement of public schooling and higher education.
One is left to wonder whether political and educational leaders view this collective deterioration of human intellect merely as acceptable collateral damage in a frantic race toward administrative modernization and technological FOMO.
However, Freire’s philosophy points toward a much darker and more deliberate possibility. An authoritarian administration, or one aspiring toward authoritarian control, might readily perceive widespread cognitive decline not as a flaw, but as a highly desirable outcome. The headlong rush to embed artificial intelligence across schools, colleges, and universities forces society to confront the very real prospect of systematized intellectual oppression, even if rare and isolated contexts exist where an exceptional educator might harness the technology to genuine pedagogical benefit.
This raises a fundamental question for society: Is this truly the future we desire? Are we willing to trade the deeply humanizing power of education for a technocratic vision centered on an automated, compliant population? The answer among many educators and scholars is an emphatic no. Consequently, any effective response to this crisis must take root in active resistance against the normalization of AI in learning environments.
In their rallying cry for academic pushback, scholars Sonja Drimmer and Christopher J. Nygren have outlined practical avenues for resisting the pervasive infiltration of AI in education. Their approach centers on open dialogue among colleagues, keeping students at the center of the pedagogical mission, and—most importantly—rejecting at every turn the foundational premise that artificial intelligence holds any legitimate place in contemporary learning spaces.
This perspective offers actionable wisdom for a system under pressure. Safeguarding the core project of education, protecting the institutional missions of our schools and universities, and defending the bedrock of democratic society requires educators to first refuse the terms and rationales presented to them as unassailable. From that point of refusal, we can return to the teachings of Paulo Freire: instructing students how to think freely, wrestle with difficult questions, and cast a deeply critical, inquisitive lens upon their own educational development.
While some critics may argue that such warnings are alarmist, the larger historical danger lies in the reality that society has not protested nearly enough. The potential consequences of failing to address this technological encroachment could prove irreversible.
Joshua Eyler is senior director of the Center for Excellence in Teaching and Learning and assistant professor of teacher education at the University of Mississippi.