Long before a manuscript finds its way onto a bookstore shelf or achieves critical acclaim, it typically begins its life as something far less glamorous: a messy, uneven first draft. According to literary agent and author Kate McKean, the creative reality of writing books is widely misunderstood by the general public, largely because society views basic literacy as an automatic qualification for producing publishable literature. In a recent essay published in Lit Hub’s Craft of Writing newsletter, McKean drew a parallel between the painstaking, often frustrating process of writing and the tactile craft of knitting, offering a grounded perspective on why early drafts are bound to be flawed and why mastery takes a lifetime of trial and error.
McKean uses the metaphor of knitting a scarf to illustrate the evolution of a writer. Just as a beginner’s first knitting project is often a lopsided, acrylic scarf that resembles a river on a map rather than a straight line, a writer’s debut novel is rarely a masterpiece. It is clumsy and irregular, yet the creator holds a deep, sentimental attachment to it. Over time, as a crafter takes on more complex patterns—learning the agonizing necessity of ripping out flawed rows and starting over—their technical skill improves. They begin to understand the importance of material quality, investing in better yarn, only to discover that the new yarn does not always suit their intended project.
Eventually, the crafter attempts a sweater, navigating complicated measurements, worrying over color choices, and facing the vulnerability of sharing their progress online. When the finished garment finally receives praise, it can be a euphoric validation, though it is often followed by the quiet sting of comparing one’s work to the flawless pieces crafted by seasoned veterans.
McKean argues that this exact emotional and technical trajectory mirrors the life of an author, yet the public rarely grants writers the same grace. Because nearly everyone learns how to construct basic sentences in elementary school, there is a widespread societal expectation that combining those sentences into a book should yield a functional, commercially viable product right from the start. When a book fails to sell or secure praise, disappointed authors are quick to point fingers at literary agents, editors, or readers, rather than accepting that the craft requires far more than merely finishing a draft.
The core misconception, McKean notes, is that the act of finishing a project automatically makes it good. While virtually any writer will readily acknowledge that writing is a craft when asked on the record, off-the-record confessions often reveal a deep, persistent shock whenever a completed manuscript fails to work, find a publisher, or win praise. Authors ask themselves why finishing a book isn’t enough.
Drawing from her own extensive career, McKean brings a unique dual perspective to the discussion. As both a published author and a literary agent with over two decades of publishing industry experience, she understands the creative struggle from every angle. Having written five picture books, two novels, and two non-fiction works—most of which were submitted to major publishing houses by her agent—she knows firsthand that numerical output does not equate to guaranteed success. Out of her own nine creative "sweaters," only two have secured book deals.

Despite spending twenty years on the inside of the publishing industry, McKean admits that her professional background did not grant her any shortcut cheat codes or guarantee immediate acceptance for her own writing. It took seven years and numerous submissions before her first book deal materialized, and she has since completed another manuscript that ultimately did not find a home. Knowing industry insiders and successfully selling a prior book, she explains, does not magically throw open the doors for every subsequent project.
This unvarnished reality check highlights a dangerous trap for creative professionals. McKean has watched promising writers wither away when their early attempts failed to meet outsized expectations, and she has witnessed talented individuals grow deeply frustrated when their books missed out on major book deals, bestseller lists, or prestigious awards. Others exhaust themselves chasing commercial trends in a desperate attempt to make a project fit, only to realize that the mold was never meant for them.
The writers who ultimately endure and succeed, McKean suggests, are those who embrace the unglamorous work of ripping out bad stitches. They are the ones who can step back to evaluate a project objectively on its own merits, recognizing that past attempts serve only as learning tools and that future success is never guaranteed.
Ultimately, McKean emphasizes that treating writing as a craft is not merely a pretentious sentiment echoed in university MFA programs. It is an acknowledgment that writing is demanding physical and mental labor that requires relentless practice, patience, and time. Expecting to never drop a stitch again simply because one initial project turned out well is a recipe for perpetual disappointment. A single completed book does not instantly elevate an author to the status of a master craftsperson—a humbling truth that seasoned creators have known all along.
The essay serves as a centerpiece for McKean’s broader exploration of the publishing industry and creative resilience. Her insights are expanded further in her book, Write Through It: An Insider’s Guide to Publishing and the Creative Life, which is available through Simon Element.