It has been 14 months since Tom Alter was abruptly and publicly fired from his tenured position as a history professor at Texas State University. The story of his dismissal sent shockwaves through the higher education community: Texas State President Kelly Damphousse, acting under intense pressure from state Republicans including outgoing Governor Greg Abbott, announced on Facebook that Alter was terminated for allegedly "inciting violence." The accusation stemmed from Alter discussing anarchist organizing tactics during an online socialism conference that he attended strictly in his personal capacity.
Alter has fought the decision from his very first day out of work, finding himself locked in an ongoing legal battle with the university for reinstatement. Now, as Texas voters have ushered in a new regime of Democratic leaders during a pivotal Election Day, the legal and political landscape in which Alter and several other ousted professors are fighting has grown noticeably brighter.
"I have to be kind of guarded," Alter said, "but it was Governor Abbott that ordered my firing, and it was Ken Paxton’s attorney general’s office that was representing Texas State and contesting my lawsuit for reinstatement, and both of them are gone now. So I can’t help but be optimistic."
A Systematic Pressure Campaign on Higher Education
For years, the Texas Legislature and university governing boards have handed down a series of restrictive laws and internal policies designed to limit academic freedom and shared governance at public institutions across the state. Within this climate, top-tier Republican politicians frequently pulled the strings in individual campus disputes, intervening directly in personnel and administrative decisions.
Following public pressure from a coalition of conservative figures—including Governor Abbott, Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick, state representatives Andy Hopper and Brian Harrison, and Abbott’s senior adviser Nate Schatzline—the Texas A&M system ousted former instructor Melissa McCoul in September 2025. Abbott had publicly alleged that McCoul "acted contrary to Texas law" by discussing gender identity during an English lecture. Like Alter, McCoul is currently fighting her termination in court.
That same month, Abbott prompted Texas State University to expel a student for imitating the death of conservative activist Charlie Kirk. He also weighed in publicly on the University of Texas’s decision to remove psychology professor Art Markman from his administrative position, writing on social media that Texas was actively "targeting professors who are more focused on pushing leftist ideologies rather than preparing students to lead our nation."
With Abbott, Patrick, Paxton, and other key Republican lawmakers on their way out of office, Alter suspects that university presidents across the state will think twice before bowing to political pressure to discipline faculty members for their speech.
"These university presidents who have been willing participants in the dismantling of higher education across Texas, they no longer have their masters behind them," Alter said. "You don’t have Abbott giving the orders, and you don’t have Paxton providing the muscle."
The Long Road Ahead for University Governance
While the political winds in Austin are shifting, systemic changes within public universities will take time. Texas Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa will soon hold the constitutional power to appoint new members to state university boards of regents, a move that could introduce "some important dissenting voices," according to Clyde Barrow, a political science professor at the University of Texas Rio Grande Valley.
Still, Barrow notes that Hinojosa’s board appointments must ultimately be approved by the state Senate, which will remain under Republican control. Furthermore, it will take several years for Democrats to gain any semblance of working control over university governing boards because current members serve staggered, multiyear terms.

Barrow knows firsthand the grinding nature of institutional inertia. He has been suspended from his campus for over a year and a half, placed on administrative leave in May 2025 while the university investigates what College of Liberal Arts Dean José Dávila-Montes termed in an email notice as "allegations of possible [rules] violations" and "inappropriate conduct." Barrow, who shared the notice with Inside Higher Ed, states that he still has not received any concrete information regarding what specific rules he may have violated. Instead, he firmly believes he is being punished for speaking critically about university administrators and administrative policies. Neither Barrow nor his legal counsel has heard directly from university officials in over a year.
He has yet to formally take his case to court, remaining mindful of the procedural hurdles inherent in employment law.
"Courts will typically not get involved in anything involving higher education until you’ve exhausted all of the internal university processes," Barrow said. "So, one way to keep it out of court is to just not exhaust the process. Don’t move it forward and just sit on it—that’s what they’re doing now."
To break the administrative deadlock, Barrow is actively considering asking the court for a writ of mandamus, a legal mechanism that would compel UTRGV administrators to finally complete their stagnant investigation.
"I’ve asked my attorney about it. He was initially nervous because of the state of courts in Texas, but that has also changed now," he said.
A New Dynamic at the Attorney General’s Office
The arrival of incoming state Attorney General Nathan Johnson, a Democrat, could dramatically alter the strategic calculus for faculty members fighting their institutions. Johnson may prove far more willing to compel public universities to turn over internal emails, meeting notes, and other vital documents during the discovery phase of litigation, materials that could greatly assist plaintiffs.
Under the previous administration, "Ken Paxton’s office always ruled in favor of the university, so it made it difficult for you to collect the information you need to go to court and be effective," Barrow noted. Beyond discovery, Johnson may simply lack the institutional interest in aggressively defending these controversial employment decisions.
"Let’s say [UTRGV] decides they want to terminate, and then I go to court. Anytime something goes to court, it’s the attorney general’s office who takes that case, not the university attorneys," Barrow explained. "So the new attorney general could very well just say, ‘I’m not taking any more of these cases. Go settle it.’"
The impact of the attorney general’s office is already visible in ongoing proceedings. Paxton’s office recently argued in Alter’s case that the fired professor should not be permitted to sue for job reinstatement, but should instead be limited strictly to financial damages. When a state court disagreed with that limitation, Alter called it "a real victory." However, the attorney general’s office immediately appealed the decision.
"That was a real blow because the appeal—just on that particular motion—could take a year, and then it could be another year after that before [the case] actually goes to trial. So I was looking at two, possibly three years before this whole thing would be resolved, and that was really daunting," Alter said. "But now that there’s a new attorney general in Texas, and a new governor, and we’ll have to see. We’re optimistic that they’ll do the right thing."