The tension at the heart of this debate is not theoretical; it is visible in the actions and policy shifts of major academic bodies over recent years. Consider, for example, the trajectory of the Middle East Studies Association (MESA). MESA was originally established for the express purpose of promoting the serious study of the Middle East. Yet, in 2021, the organization formally declared a “dual commitment to scholarship and advocacy.” The very following year, MESA took a decisive step that undermined its foundational mission by endorsing an academic boycott of Israel.

By its very nature, an academic boycott seeks to restrict scholarly collaboration, dialogue, and exchange, thereby constraining the production and transmission of knowledge about a country that is central to the field of Middle East studies. Yet, in the very report that Wilson defends, MESA invokes the lofty language of academic freedom to defend political activism that is tightly aligned with its own partisan, anti-Israel agenda. This creates an irreconcilable paradox: How can an organization that actively supports restricting scholarship for political ends be trusted to promote and safeguard that same scholarship?

The trajectory of the AAUP presents an even more troubling set of contradictions. In 2006, the AAUP rightly and forcefully condemned academic boycotts as fundamentally inimical to the principles of academic freedom. But by 2024, with supporters of the academic Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement occupying key leadership positions related to academic freedom within the organization, the AAUP reversed that long-standing policy.

How can an organization entrusted with protecting academic freedom retain its institutional credibility after abandoning its historical opposition to a campaign that clearly restricts the academic freedom and educational opportunities of students and scholars? Strikingly, Wilson addresses neither of these profound contradictions in his commentary. He insists strenuously that there is no “political activism” exception to academic freedom, but he never explains how that freedom could possibly justify activism that suppresses scholarship and restricts the academic freedom of others.

Wilson’s sweeping defense of faculty political activism also carries sweeping and dangerous implications for universities themselves. When professors use their unique academic authority to pressure students into participating in political campaigns, impose political litmus tests, or restrict scholarly opportunities for political ends, they are effectively subordinating their core educational and scholarly responsibilities to partisan politics.

What, then, are the actual limits of academic freedom when political activism directly conflicts with a professor’s fundamental responsibilities to teach and pursue objective scholarship, or when it infringes upon the academic freedom of students and colleagues? Wilson and other staunch defenders of academic freedom have a particular professional and ethical responsibility to answer this question forthrightly. To invoke academic freedom as a blanket defense of political activism without ever confronting those limits is to completely abdicate that responsibility.

Tammi Rossman-Benjamin
Co-founder and director, AMCHA Initiative

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *