A trusted colleague mentioned

in a meeting recently that she has never seen students more stressed out than she sees now. She is not the type who is prone to drama, so when she declared student stress the worst she’s ever seen, it caught immediate attention and set off a broader reflection on the psychological climate of contemporary higher education.

From the outside, conventional logic might suggest that the farther away society gets from the worst of the COVID-19 pandemic, the closer campuses would return to a familiar sense of normal. Yet, when examining student perceptions, that expectation simply does not hold true. The emotional reality on the ground tells a distinctly different story, one defined by a unique convergence of economic pressures and technological disruption that separates this moment from any previous era in recent memory.

A Changing Economic Landscape: Comparing Past Crises to the Present

The world that students are facing today is meaningfully different now than it was during the last couple of major societal crises. When the economy’s wheels came off in 2008 during the Great Recession, people flocked to higher education in droves. Enrollments hit historic peaks around 2009 and 2010 as the opportunity cost of obtaining a degree hit a new low. The rest of the broader economy was contracting hard, but college campuses remained lively hubs of activity.

During that period, online classes accounted for a much smaller proportion of total institutional offerings, meaning physical campuses were densely populated and deeply social. Campuses felt very much like oases from the brutal recession outside their gates. More importantly, there was a general, reassuring sense among the student body that as bad as things were at the moment, the economy would eventually recover and normal career pathways would reopen.

When the global pandemic hit in 2020, anxiety spiked dramatically across the board, but much of that psychological distress was invisible from a traditional campus perspective as institutions shifted to remote learning. Even then, at least for a sustained period, there seemed to be a collective cultural belief that this unprecedented disruption too would pass. The immediate moment had an undeniable surreal feeling to it for obvious reasons, but students still retained a fundamental sense of hope that there would be viable opportunities waiting for them on the other side of graduation.

Over the course of the last year or so, however, a couple of subtler, more insidious changes have set in. Students felt the impact of these shifts almost immediately, altering their daily calculus of survival and ambition.

Daily Pressures: Gas Prices and the Cost of Living

One major factor has been the sharp and sustained spike in gas prices, which accelerated immediately after geopolitical tensions and conflicts arose overseas, such as the disruptions linked to the Iran war. Prices jumped by roughly $1.50 a gallon in the early spring across many regions and have remained stubbornly elevated—hovering about $1.30 more per gallon than they were just a year prior.

In many regions, public transit systems are modest at best, meaning the vast majority of students rely on personal automobiles to commute to campus, internships, and essential part-time jobs. When an individual is already struggling to pay rising tuition bills and keep themselves fed, an abrupt and sustained double-digit percentage increase in the cost of driving hits extraordinarily hard.

Had the price spike lasted merely a few weeks, it would have been an annoying budgetary pinch. Because it has persisted for the better part of a year, it has hardened into a genuine, grinding obstacle for individuals and families living paycheck to paycheck. This everyday financial friction quietly compounds the mental load carried by learners who are already stretched to their absolute financial limits. It is a persistent background stressor that wears down emotional resilience over time.

The Technological Threat: Artificial Intelligence and the Entry-Level Job Market

The second major structural shift is the rapid emergence of artificial intelligence and its unsettling effect on the entry-level job market. Unless a student is pursuing a degree in health care or one of a select few specialized skilled trades—with the latter currently receiving a boost from the physical expansion of data centers and digital infrastructure—it is no longer entirely clear which career fields offer a genuinely secure, predictable future.

This uncertainty makes it remarkably easy for young people to give in to what commentator Kyla Scanlon has aptly described as financial nihilism. It is one thing for a young person to endure significant personal sacrifice, debt, and exhaustion for an education that offers a plausible and deeply appealing professional payoff at the end. It is quite another thing entirely to sacrifice precious years and scarce financial resources for an educational credential that feels increasingly like a reflection of a world that is already on its way out.

The combination of these economic and technological pressures, from the perspective of someone just starting out in adult life, can be profoundly demotivating. Higher education suddenly appears both harder to access and less obviously reliable as a direct route to the middle class. While online classes can help alleviate some of the transportation and commuting burdens brought on by high gas prices, students who rely heavily on virtual learning often find themselves feeling isolated. This isolation carries well-documented negative effects for student retention, degree completion, and deep learning. That toxic combination of social isolation and a felt sense of pointlessness can ultimately lead to all manner of acute anxiety and mental exhaustion.

An Undefinable Future

This psychological climate represents a fundamental departure from the last couple of major crises. As intensely difficult as the Great Recession and the pandemic were from one another, neither appeared to fundamentally threaten the structural foundation of the long-term economy. They both felt like intense, violent storms that would eventually pass; at some inevitable point, the familiar concept of normal would return.

By contrast, the rise of artificial intelligence threatens to hollow out better-paying entry-level and mid-level professional jobs, potentially preventing the previous normal from ever returning in its old form. Individuals who are already well-established in their professional careers may possess the seniority and stability to ride out the clock until retirement, but young people trying to break into the workforce for the first time are facing a genuinely undefinable future.

Young adulthood is inherently a stressful developmental stage under the best of conditions, as individuals naturally try to figure out who they are, what their values are, and what their ultimate place in the world will be. When the broader world is made significantly less legible and predictable, that foundational stress is magnified exponentially.

To the extent that educational institutions and educators can possibly manage it, they owe it to their students to help build the versatile, durable skills likely to matter in any future economic landscape. Furthermore, institutions owe students whatever honesty and clarity can realistically be offered about the complex world they will inhabit long after the current generation of educators has stepped aside.