For more than a decade, educators and academic leaders have wrestled with how to define the liberal arts in an era increasingly dominated by pre-professional training and STEM specialization. Yet, according to long-time academic and administrator Gerald R. Greenberg, the liberal arts stubbornly resist the kind of rigid definitions that contemporary institutions crave. Much like the Tao of ancient philosophy, a true liberal education cannot be neatly named or strictly delimited without fundamentally diminishing what it actually is. It can only be experienced, lived, and moved through.

Throughout his career, Greenberg has argued that examining what "liberal" truly means and defending the humanities in a technology-driven age requires looking far beyond standard curriculum design. Instead, he suggests that a liberal education embodies a dynamic pattern—one that Taoist philosophy describes directly through the interplay of complementary forces, even when academic institutions fail to articulate it.

The underlying architecture of this educational tradition mirrors the classical concept of yin and yang: two poles that are endlessly distinct yet perpetually entwined, with each containing the seed of the other. In the traditional symbol, the white field holds a black dot, and the black field holds a white dot, demonstrating that no single mode of understanding is ever entirely self-sufficient. When pushed to its furthest extent, any academic discipline inevitably discovers the foundational principles of its apparent opposite living quietly within it.

When applied to higher education, setting the humanities and the sciences as the two primary poles of learning reveals this pattern with remarkable precision. Traditional humanities disciplines—such as literature, history, philosophy, language, and art—cultivate meaning, interpretation, and the qualitative texture of human experience. Conversely, the sciences and mathematics cultivate measurement, prediction, and formal structural analysis.

When taught in total isolation, however, both poles risk calcification. Science without humanistic reflection possesses the capacity to measure everything while remaining blind to why those measurements matter. Similarly, humanities instruction devoid of empirical rigor can easily generate abstract interpretations entirely untethered from how the physical world actually behaves.

When taught as intended within a genuine liberal arts core, however, each academic pole carries the seed of its counterpart. Mathematics functions as an ancient humanistic art rooted in pattern and abstraction, bearing a much closer resemblance to poetry than many modern advocates of science, technology, engineering, and math are willing to admit. In parallel, literature and history demand the exact same disciplined attention to evidence, structure, and falsifiable claims that any rigorous laboratory experiment requires.

This interconnected dualism is far from a modern pedagogical discovery. The classical liberal arts tradition already embodied this exact synthesis centuries ago. The traditional trivium—comprising grammar, logic, and rhetoric—is typically categorized among the humanities. Yet logic operates as a formal discipline of valid inference that is structurally akin to mathematics.

Meanwhile, the historic quadrivium—consisting of arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music—is generally filed under the mathematical arts. Historically, however, music was studied for centuries through the complex language of harmonic ratios and proportions, serving just as much as a humanistic pursuit of beauty as it did a mathematical science. The medieval curriculum successfully contained the exact pattern that Taoist philosophy names, with each intellectual pole carrying the seed of its opposite in plain sight.

This inherent resistance to closed lists and rigid categorizations is not an accidental feature of the liberal arts; it is the core of the argument itself. The foundational texts of Taoism begin by warning that any eternal principle that can be strictly named ceases to be the true principle. Once a concept is delimited, fixed, and itemized, it stops representing the living reality.

The exact same principle applies to modern higher education. The moment a university course catalog, a general education committee, or an academic dean attempts to specify once and for all which departments belong to the liberal arts and which are merely adjacent, something essential is lost. The liberal arts were never a permanent property of specific administrative departments in the first place; they are fundamentally a property of intellectual perspective.

Consider how this perspective manifests in the classroom. A film studies course housed within an English department—asking probing questions about what a film means, how it constructs an argument, and what historical traditions it addresses—belongs securely to the liberal arts. This classification does not apply simply because the word "English" appears on the department door, but because the course is taught from an inquiring, interpretive stance.

Conversely, a technical film production course focusing on the mechanical craft of lighting, editing, and sound design may be taught just two doors down by equally dedicated instructors. While valuable in its own right, that technical course is not automatically transformed into a liberal art merely by sharing geographical proximity to one.

Ultimately, the true benefit of a liberal education has never been located inside any single course syllabus, nor even within the contents of a specific academic discipline. Instead, it resides in the sustained practice of moving fluidly across a variety of modes of inquiry. It is the cultivated habit of thinking mathematically one hour and historically the next, of testing a concrete hypothesis and then deeply interrogating a complex text, until that movement itself becomes a natural way of engaging with the wider world. The student who merely memorizes which departments satisfy specific graduation requirements has simply learned a university schedule. The student who has been fundamentally changed by moving through those diverse disciplines has learned the true Tao of the liberal arts.

Between the two traditional extremes lie the social sciences, occupying the swirling boundary where the black and white dots meet. Economics borrows sophisticated mathematical modeling to illuminate irreducibly human behavior; psychology utilizes controlled experiments to investigate human meaning and internal motive; and anthropology moves fluidly between statistical methodologies and deep interpretive analysis. These fields serve as visible proof that the boundary separating the humanities from the sciences was never a solid wall.

Historical precedent confirms this integrative pattern far more often than the modern cultural divide between STEM and the humanities would suggest. When Johannes Kepler successfully discovered the fundamental laws of planetary motion, he was actively pursuing what he sincerely believed was a musical and theological harmony governing the cosmos. His groundbreaking scientific discoveries were utterly inseparable from his humanistic conviction that the universe was constructed according to strict principles of beauty and proportion.

Similarly, Alexander von Humboldt, whose meticulous observations fundamentally reshaped modern ecology and geography, wrote about the natural world in a register much closer to Romantic poetry than to a standard laboratory notebook. It was precisely this rare synthesis—feeling married directly to rigorous measurement—that allowed Humboldt to perceive vast connections across disciplines that narrower specialists consistently missed.

A similar convergence enabled monumental breakthroughs in the life sciences. Rosalind Franklin’s advanced X-ray crystallography provided James Watson and Francis Crick with the crucial physical evidence needed to understand the structure of the DNA double helix. However, the imaginative leap required to build a structural model—the interpretive act of reading a compelling story within raw data—was fundamentally a humanistic move, relying on the type of pattern recognition that advanced literary training fosters.

Noam Chomsky’s revolutionary work in linguistics similarly helped found the entire field of cognitive science and heavily influenced early computer science precisely because he treated human language, arguably the most humanistic of all subjects, as a formal mathematical system worthy of rigorous modeling.

None of these historic breakthroughs occurred because a scientist temporarily borrowed a tool from a humanist, or vice versa. They happened because, for a brief yet critical moment, the artificial wall between the two intellectual poles completely dissolved, allowing thinkers to move with the grain of the entire pattern rather than forcing one mode of thought to dominate another.

This dynamic approaches what Taoism describes as wu wei—not passivity, but action so perfectly aligned with the actual shape of a problem that unnecessary force becomes obsolete. Just as the legendary cook in classical Chinese philosophy carves an ox effortlessly by finding the natural spaces already existing between bone and joint, the scholar who allows humanistic and scientific modes of thought to flow through one another discovers the intellectual spaces that already exist between traditional academic disciplines.

This is precisely why a liberal arts education, when pursued honestly, cannot be reduced to a bureaucratic checklist of distribution requirements to be checked off on the path to a major. Each curricular requirement should not be viewed as an arbitrary obstacle, but as a path—part of a continually rotating wheel where the sciences illuminate the humanities and the humanities illuminate the sciences in an endless cycle. One does not truly finish the liberal arts; rather, one gradually learns to move in harmony with them.

For university administrators and faculty members who genuinely wish to honor this underlying pattern rather than simply paying lip service to it, the starting point requires asking a fundamentally different question. Instead of asking which administrative box a specific course checks, educators should ask where the course sits on the broader wheel, what it is in genuine conversation with, how its goals are taught, and how it speaks to other courses across the core curriculum.

Adopting this perspective may still produce a course list, and that list will undoubtedly evolve over time. Yet doing so will help protect the liberal arts from deteriorating into a mundane administrative checklist, transforming the educational experience into something genuinely beneficial that prepares students to navigate their own lives and the societies they will ultimately shape with lasting intellectual fluency.

Gerald R. Greenberg is emeritus associate professor of Russian and linguistics and former senior associate dean of the College of Arts and Sciences at Syracuse University.