Pending home sales descended to a new all-time low in October as mortgage rates surged to a three-year peak, keeping would-be buyers firmly on the sidelines and driving transaction volumes down to levels not seen in decades.
Contract signings fell 4.7% compared to September, and plummeted 16.7% year over year, according to the National Association of Realtors® Pending Home Sales report released on Wednesday. The stark decline underscores a deeply challenged housing market where persistent affordability hurdles continue to frustrate buyers and paralyze market activity heading into the final stretch of the year.
"October could mark the low point in contract signings for this housing cycle, as mortgage rates appear to have topped out," says NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun.
The October readout comes directly on the heels of the previous record low set in September, when pending sales fell 7.3% month over month and 11.3% year over year. The consecutive months of historic lows highlight a compounding slowdown across the American residential real estate landscape.
"Two consecutive months of record-low pending contracts point to very sluggish fourth-quarter home sales closings, and annual existing-home sales could be the lowest since the mid-1990s," says Yun.
Geographically, the cool-down was widespread. Same as in September, pending sales were down both month over month and year over year in all four major U.S. regions. The West saw the largest monthly pullback with a 6.9% drop, followed by the South with a 6.3% decrease, the Midwest down 2.7%, and the Northeast declining 0.8%.
On an annual basis, the West was once again at the forefront of the contraction with a staggering 20.3% drop. It was followed by the South, which saw an 18.7% decline, the Midwest down 14%, and the Northeast experiencing an 11.1% fall.
Despite the broad regional declines, real estate analysts point out that certain areas have demonstrated relative resilience.
"Even though all four regions saw dramatic cooling, the relative strength of the Midwest and Northeast are clear, due largely to still-scarce inventory conditions," says Realtor.com® senior economist Hannah Jones.
At the metro level, pending sales fell year over year even in markets that had previously proven to be the most resilient against macroeconomic headwinds. Across the nation’s 50 largest metropolitan areas, the smallest decreases were recorded in Cincinnati, Ohio, where sales fell 4.7% year over year; Austin, Texas, down 9.7%; and Hartford, Connecticut, which experienced a 10% decline.
The broader disconnect between demographic realities and transaction volume remains a central mystery for market observers.
"It is somewhat puzzling that home sales would fall to levels last seen three decades ago, even as the U.S. population has grown by roughly 75 million," notes Yun. "Either sizable housing demand is building in the background, or the dream of homeownership is increasingly out of reach for many Americans."
The primary driver behind the October slump was a sharp spike in borrowing costs. On October 8, the average rate on 30-year fixed home loans reached 7.40%, marking the highest level since November 2023 and severely eroding the purchasing power of active home seekers. While rates have retreated somewhat in the weeks following that peak, October’s hot inflation data, released later in the month, has fueled expectations that rates could climb upward once again.
"Until inflation cools enough to put mortgage rates on a downward path, affordability problems are likely to persist, keeping contract signings and home sales subdued," says Jones.
Metros with the smallest pending sales declines in October
While the national trend pointed firmly downward, a handful of metropolitan areas managed to limit their losses. Cincinnati, Ohio, led the nation’s largest metros with a modest 4.7% year-over-year decline in pending home sales. Austin, Texas, followed with a 9.7% drop, while Hartford, Connecticut, rounded out the top three most resilient large markets with a 10% decrease compared to the same period a year prior.
What this means for buyers this fall
Navigating the autumn housing market has presented a complex set of challenges and opportunities for prospective homeowners. Jones suggests that while uncertainty preceding the November midterm elections may have played a role in stalling homebuying activity, she strongly believes that surging mortgage rates were the far more likely culprit behind the market freeze.
Mortgage rates climbed nearly 75 basis points from late August to mid-October, adding roughly $200 a month to the typical mortgage payment on a median-priced home, assuming a standard 10% down payment.
"That is more than many already-strained buyers can easily absorb," argues Jones.
According to the economist, affordability remains the single most restrictive limiting factor in today’s housing market. The typical existing mortgage-holder would see a staggering $1,100 increase in their monthly payment if they were to buy a median-priced home at current market rates, a phenomenon widely referred to as the lock-in effect that has kept millions of potential sellers from listing their properties.
While sellers have shown some degree of flexibility, responding to the slow market with lower asking prices and a higher frequency of price cuts, buyers have not rushed forward with much enthusiasm given the high cost of debt.
"Sellers are only willing to come down so far and buyers are only willing to stretch so far, and a gap still separates the two," adds Jones.
As a direct consequence of this standoff, transaction volume in October hit its lowest level in 16 years. However, industry experts note that the subdued environment offers distinct silver linings for buyers who possess the financial stability to act. Those who enter the market today face significantly less competition, a wider selection of homes to choose from, and sellers who are increasingly motivated to negotiate on terms and price.